Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦
Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦Now accepting custom orders — handmade with love, just for you! 🎂✦
Birdie'sBaking Co.
Peanut butter pie in a chocolate crust with whipped cream and chopped Reese's cups on top, handmade in Columbia City, IN
Pie

Peanut Butter Pie

Our Peanut Butter Pie is handmade in Columbia City, IN for pickup in the greater Fort Wayne area. A whipped peanut butter and cream cheese filling is piled into a crisp chocolate cookie crust, then topped with house-whipped cream and chopped Reese's peanut butter cups. A 9-inch pie serves 8 and needs 48 hours notice. Served chilled.

$25.00
Choose your decoration

Curious how the hand-cut florals are made? See our pie-crust florals page — a Birdie's Baking Co. signature finish unavailable elsewhere in Fort Wayne, Columbia City, or Warsaw.

Serving Size
9-inch pie, serves 8
Lead Time
48 hours

Allergen Disclosure

Contains: peanuts, wheat, dairy, soy.

Made in a kitchen that handles wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and soy.

  • Keep refrigerated until serving

Ingredients

  • creamy peanut butter
  • cream cheese
  • powdered sugar
  • heavy cream
  • pure vanilla extract
  • chocolate cookie crust (wheat flour, cocoa, butter, sugar)
  • Reese's peanut butter cups

Frequently Asked Questions

What allergens are in the Peanut Butter Pie?

Contains peanuts, wheat, dairy, and soy. This is one of our most allergen-heavy pies. Made in a kitchen that also handles tree nuts and eggs.

Does it need to be refrigerated?

Yes. Keep the pie refrigerated until serving. The filling is a chilled, mousse-style cream.

How much notice do you need?

Peanut Butter Pies need 48 hours notice. Order online and pick up at our Columbia City, IN location Friday through Sunday.

How many people does it serve?

One 9-inch pie serves 8 generous slices, perfect for a family gathering or office potluck in Fort Wayne.

You might also like

Apple Pie — handmade pie by Birdie's Baking Co.pie

Apple Pie

A variety of sliced apples baked with sugar and warm spices in a flaky, golden crust.

From $25.00
Dutch Apple Pie — handmade pie by Birdie's Baking Co.pie

Dutch Apple Pie

A variety of sliced apples baked with cinnamon and sugar and topped with a buttery crumble inside a flaky crust.

From $25.00
Cherry Pie — handmade pie by Birdie's Baking Co.pie

Cherry Pie

Sweet and tart cherries baked in a flaky, golden crust.

From $25.00
View the full menu